Digital Brain
digital brain
digital brain

Bill C-49: Is the Line Haul Interswitching Remedy Really New?

May 2017 Transportation Bulletin 2 minute read

As we recently reported, the Government of Canada has introduced the “Transportation Modernization Act” (Bill C-49) into the House, which would amend the Canada Transportation Act (the “CTA”).  Among other things, Bill C-49 proposes a new rail shipper remedy to be known as “long-haul interswitching” (“LHI”).

The LHI remedy would allow a shipper that has access to only one class 1 rail carrier (the local carrier) at a point of origin or destination to apply to the Canadian Transportation Agency for a “long haul interswitching order”.  The order would require the local carrier to transport the shipper’s traffic from that point to the nearest interchange at a rate determined by the Agency, for furtherance beyond by a connecting federal railway company.  We have compared the LHI remedy to the existing competitive line rate (“CLR”) remedy, which Bill C-49 seeks to repeal.

The National Transportation Act Review Commission as far back as 1993 found the CLR remedy had been rendered “largely inoperative” in Canada because CN and CP had simply declined to compete with each other through CLRs.  Some shippers expressed a concern about a prerequisite to its use (namely, agreement with the connecting carrier). The LHI remedy removes that prerequisite.  However, a bigger obstacle to the use of the CLR remedy is whether the terms imposed by the connecting carrier, including the rate, are acceptable.  The LHI remedy does not overcome this obstacle in any way.

The LHI remedy is also considerably more restrictive than the CLR remedy has ever been. In part, this is because it significantly limits the range of potential applicants.  We have prepared a summary, available upon request from the authors, that identifies many of these limitations and contrasts the LHI and CLR remedies in various key respects.

Despite these restrictions, some shippers may find the LHI remedy useful.  For example, shippers with facilities in Alberta, Saskatchewan or Manitoba that benefit from the current Zone 5 interswitching distance of 160 kilometres may seek to rely upon the LHI remedy when this Zone is eliminated on August 1.  Also, some eligible shippers with facilities located outside those three provinces may be able to use the LHI remedy to reach an interchange with a carrier that is willing to compete for the traffic.  Other means may exist that are more helpful to those and other shippers, however.

Please do not hesitate to contact us if you wish to set up a private briefing to discuss the LHI remedy, Bill C-49 or any of the other shipper remedies under the CTA.

Strategy, Negotiations, Resolution

(from left to right: Louis Zivot, Lucia StuhldreierRyan Gallagher, François Tougas – Co-Chair)

by François Tougas, Lucia Stuhldreier and Ryan Gallagher

A Cautionary Note

The foregoing provides only an overview and does not constitute legal advice. Readers are cautioned against making any decisions based on this material alone. Rather, specific legal advice should be obtained.

© McMillan LLP 2017

Insights (5 Posts)

Featured Insight

Learning to Live with COVID-19: Ontario Releases Amendments Setting Out New Requirements as of January 31, 2022

The Government of Ontario has released the latest amendments to O. Reg 364/20, setting out new requirements for employers as of January 31, 2022.

Read More
Jan 28, 2022
Featured Insight

FSRA Releases Final Innovation Framework and Opens Testing Environment for Auto Insurance Innovations

SRA recently announced their Final Innovation Framework and Test and Learn Environment Guidance, a positive step forward for financial services innovators.

Read More
Jan 26, 2022
Featured Insight

Getting the Deal Through – Cartel Regulations 2022

Lexology Getting the Deal Through – Cartel Regulations 2022 provides a detailed explanation of how cartel regimes work in practice, including recent developments over the past year and an overview of future changes expected in each jurisdiction.

Read More
Jan 26, 2022
Featured Insight

BC Government Published Workplace Safety Order Mandating COVID-19 Safety Plans

On January 20, 2022, the BC Government published the Workplace Safety order mandating COVID-19 Safety Plans for certain BC workplaces.

Featured Insight

The 2022 Construction Labour “Open Period” – What Employers Need to Know

March 1 – April 30, 2022 is the “Open Period” for ICI collective agreements, and many non-ICI agreements, in Ontario. During this period members of construction unions can apply to the Ontario Labour Relations Board to terminate a union’s bargaining rights with their employer, or – more commonly – a rival union can apply to the Board to displace an existing union, in what is commonly known as a “raid”. During the Open Period employers will likely see increased union activity on sites as incumbent unions will seek to maintain member support, and as rival unions may try to gather support for a raid.

Join us on Wednesday, February 2nd for a discussion about what employers should expect and need to know if a decertification application or a displacement application involving their employees is filed at the Board.

Details
Wednesday, February 2, 2022