Digital Brain
digital brain
digital brain

“Don’t Worry, We All Know What That Clause Means” – Court Reaffirms The Importance of Carefully Drafting Fixed-Term Employment Agreements

June 2018 Employment and Labour Bulletin 2 minute read

Businesses and employees alike have been repeatedly reminded by their lawyers that employment contracts must be carefully and clearly drafted. The Ontario Superior Court recently pronounced itself on this issue in Norgren v. Plasma Power LLC.

In Norgren, the terminated plaintiff sought a ruling that his employment contract was for a 3-year, fixed-term, notwithstanding an early termination without cause from his employer. He argued that he was, therefore, entitled to be paid for the entire remaining balance of the contract upon termination. Contrary to the usual positions taken in fixed-term cases, the employer, in Norgren,  argued that the employee was (only) entitled to common law notice.

The contract contained only one statement indicating that it might be for a fixed term: “[the agreement] will time out in 3 years and the goals will be reset.” With no other language or reasonable indicator that the contract was meant to expire after three years, the Court ruled that the above phrase was insufficient to denote a fixed-term contract.

In discussing what is required for a fixed-term employment agreement, the Court wrote that it must determine whether there is any ambiguity to the language relied upon. In this case, the term “and the goals will be reset” was unambiguous, just not in the way the plaintiff employee would have liked. Rather than stipulate a fixed-term, using language that evidenced some kind of surviving obligation demonstrated an intention to have an indefinite employment term. As a rule, to find that there is a fixed-term contract requires unequivocal and unambiguous language to that effect.

As a result, the Court awarded Norgren common law notice of termination; not the full contract value which he sought.

Takeaways for Employers

Fixed-term agreements continue to be scrutinized by the courts. Norgren demonstrates the importance of using unequivocal contract language, especially when establishing a fixed-term employment contract. A Court will not find that an employee’s term of employment is fixed unless a contract explicitly says as much and lacks indicators of a contrary intention.

Interestingly, the Court was silent on Ontario Regulation 288/01 to the Employment Standards Act, 2000 “Termination and Severance of Employment”. Section 2 of the Regulation stipulates that the termination without cause entitlements in the ESA are not applicable where a contract term has expired, unless the task for which the employee was hired lasts more than 12 months or is not yet completed in 12 months. It is likely that the Court did not consider the Regulation because the employee was, at least, entitled to common law rather than the statutory notice of termination. Nevertheless, employers should be aware of this important stipulation before considering a fixed-term employment agreement.

by Kyle Lambert and Martin Thompson

A Cautionary Note

The foregoing provides only an overview and does not constitute legal advice. Readers are cautioned against making any decisions based on this material alone. Rather, specific legal advice should be obtained

Insights (5 Posts)

Featured Insight

Round One of Competition Act Amendments Passed; National Security Review Regime Amended

New amendments to the Competition Act were passed today as part of the budget implementation bill.

Read More
Jun 27, 2022
Featured Insight

Privacy Reform is on the Table Once More: Canada Introduces the Digital Charter Implementation Act, 2022

New federal privacy legislation has been introduced. If passed, Bill C-27 will materially change the legal landscape for privacy and data protection in Canada.

Read More
Jun 22, 2022
Featured Insight

Plan for the Ban: Canada Announces Timeline for Single-Use Plastics Prohibition

Canada's final Single-use Plastics Prohibition Regulations have been published and come into effect on December 20, 2022

Read More
Jun 22, 2022
Featured Insight

Canada’s Greenhouse Gas Offset Credit System Creates Green Incentives for Regulated Facilities (Update)

Canada has published the Greenhouse Gas Offset Credit System Regulations establishing a system for projects preventing or removing GHGs from the atmosphere.

Read More
Jun 21, 2022
Featured Insight

The Federal Government Suspends its Mandatory Vaccination Requirements

The Government of Canada has lifted its mandatory vaccination requirements for employees in the air, marine and rail sectors.

Read More
Jun 21, 2022