Court Considers Impact of COVID-19 Pandemic on Reasonable Notice Periods
Court Considers Impact of COVID-19 Pandemic on Reasonable Notice Periods
Ontario’s Superior Court of Justice has issued the first of likely many decisions dealing with the COVID-19 pandemic and its impact on reasonable notice periods.
Background
The employee in Yee v Hudson’s Bay Company[1] was a 62-year old Director of Product Design with 11 years of service. He was dismissed from his employment in August 2019, approximately six months before COVID-19 was characterized as a pandemic by the World Health Organization.
In support of his claim for an 18-month reasonable notice period, the employee argued that the COVID-19 pandemic had resulted in significant increased difficulty in obtaining alternate employment. In this regard, the employee’s evidence was that he had sent out approximately 90 job applications without success. He submitted that this provided a basis for awarding a reasonable notice period at the highest possible end of the appropriate range.
The trial judge disagreed. In refusing to take the COVID-19 pandemic into account, the trial judge relied on the Ontario Court of Appeal’s decision in Holland v Hostopia.com Inc., which says: “Notice is to be determined by the circumstances existing at the time of termination and not by the amount of time that it takes the employee to find employment”. In other words, because termination of employment occurred prior to the start of the pandemic, it could not be relied upon as a factor influencing the reasonable notice period owed by the employer.
However, the trial judge did leave the door open for employees dismissed after the start of the COVID-19 pandemic to argue that they may be entitled to receive longer notice periods. In the words of the trial judge:
“It seems clear terminations which occurred before the COVID pandemic and its effect on employment opportunities should not attract the same consideration as termination after the beginning of the COVID pandemic and its negative effect on finding comparable employment.”
Takeaways for Employers
There are conflicting legal decisions about the impact that a downturn in the economy should have on reasonable notice periods. On one hand, courts have held that an economic downturn may make it more difficult to find alternate employment, and this may justify a longer reasonable notice period.[2] On the other hand, Ontario’s Court of Appeal has said that difficulty in securing alternate employment should not have the effect of increasing the notice period unreasonably – e.g., when employment is unavailable due to “general economic conditions”.[3]
The impact that the COVID-19 pandemic should have on reasonable notice periods is an issue that will likely be heavily litigated in the months ahead. For now, however, employers can take some comfort in the fact that employees dismissed before the start of the COVID-19 pandemic should not receive inflated notice awards simply because a pandemic was later declared during the applicable notice period.
[2] Paquette v. TeraGo Networks, 2015 ONSC 4189; Zoldowski v Strongco Corporation, 2015 ONSC 5485.
[3] Michela v. St. Thomas of Villanova Catholic School, 2015 ONCA 801.
by David Fanjoy and Paul Boshyk
A Cautionary Note
The foregoing provides only an overview and does not constitute legal advice. Readers are cautioned against making any decisions based on this material alone. Rather, specific legal advice should be obtained.
© McMillan LLP 2021
Insights (5 Posts)View More
New Mont-Tremblant Green Tax Targets Building Construction
A Québec municipality has just adopted a green tax that applies to new building construction, to offset the impact on carbon storage
The Quick and Dirty on MORE Amendments to Ontario’s Excess Soil Regulation
When it comes to excess soil, the Ontario Ministry of Environment, Conservation and Parks is no stranger to getting its hands dirty altering the regulations.
Towards a Shared Understanding: Canada’s New Sustainable Investment Guidelines & Mandated Climate Disclosures
Canada’s New Sustainable Investment Guidelines (Taxonomy) & Mandated Climate Disclosures
2024 Corporate Counsel CPD Webinar Series: Allyship in Action: Cultivating Inclusive Workplace Cultures
In this session, Dr. Sonia Kang, PhD. from the Rotman School of Management, explores practical actions and strategies, based on her expertise in the study of organizational behaviour, that will empower participants to enact meaningful allyship and create inclusive workplace cultures.
2024 Corporate Counsel CPD Webinar Series: Enhance Performance in Multi-Generational Teams with Key Communication and Feedback Tools
Join leading strategic consultant and best-selling author, Adwoa K. Buahene, MA, who advises hundreds of Fortune-500 companies, government agencies and not-for-profit organizations, on how to build successful strategies to manage, motivate and engage different generations in the workplace.
Get updates delivered right to your inbox. You can unsubscribe at any time.