Woman making a frame around the sun with her hands at sunrise
Woman making a frame around the sun with her hands at sunrise
Woman making a frame around the sun with her hands at sunrise

Taiwan – Canada Tax Arrangement Released

January 2016 Tax Bulletin 3 minutes read

On January 15, 2016, Canada and Taiwan entered into an “Arrangement for the avoidance of double taxation and the prevention of fiscal evasion with respect to taxes on income” (the “Arrangement“). The Arrangement will apply to amounts paid or taxation years beginning after January 1 of the year following the year in which Canada and Taiwan confirm the domestic ratification of the Arrangement.

Broadly speaking, if ratified by both parties, the Arrangement will encourage cross-border business and investment, allow businesses and investors to better determine their cross-border tax exposure and obligations, and provide protection against tax discrimination and potential double-taxation.

For residents of Taiwan, the benefits of the Arrangement will include:

  • A reduced Canadian withholding tax rate of 10% on dividends paid by a Canadian-resident corporation, if the Taiwanese dividend recipient is a company that holds, directly or indirectly, at least 20% of the capital of the dividend payer. With respect to dividends paid by other Canadian-resident corporations, the dividend will normally be subject to a reduced rate of withholding tax of 15%.
  • A reduced Canadian withholding tax rate on interest payments (a withholding tax rate of 10% will generally apply in circumstances where the interest payment does not otherwise qualify for Canada’s 0% statutory withholding tax rate on conventional interest paid to an arm’s length lender).
  • A reduced Canadian withholding tax rate of 10% on royalty payments made by a Canadian resident.
  • Residency tie-breaker rules that may be of assistance to international business principals who have family or business connections in both Canada and Taiwan.

The reduced withholding tax rate of 10% on cross-border dividends is the same as the rate imposed on dividends under Canada’s tax treaty with China; however, the rate reduction is less favourable than the reduction afforded under recent Canadian tax treaties, notably Canada’s tax treaty with Hong Kong.

While the Arrangement provides that a resident of Taiwan should only be subject to Canadian tax on business profits attributable to a permanent establishment of that resident in Canada, it should be noted that the definition of a “permanent establishment” under the Arrangement is different (and potentially broader) than that typically contained in many of Canada’s tax treaties. For example, under the Arrangement, a resident of Taiwan would only be considered to have a permanent establishment in Canada in respect of a building site or construction or installation project if it lasts for more than 6 months (as opposed to the 12 month period required under many of Canada’s tax treaties). Similarly, the Arrangement includes a so-called “service permanent establishment” rule in respect of services performed in Canada, which is unusual in most of Canada’s tax treaties (with the US and China tax treaties being notable exceptions). It is worth noting that, in these and other respects, the Arrangement mirrors the provisions of Canada’s tax treaty with China.

In order to access the reduced withholding tax rates provided under the Arrangement, a Taiwanese company must have a sufficient nexus to Taiwan. In this regard, consideration must be given to the potential application of anti-avoidance provisions contained in the Arrangement that deny the ability to claim the benefits afforded by the Arrangement where, among other things, steps were taken to position a particular person to qualify for benefits under the Arrangement. The special anti-avoidance rules in the Arrangement are comparable to the anti-avoidance provisions that have been included in several recent Canadian tax treaties, including the Canada-Hong Kong treaty.

For Canadian companies, one might expect that one benefit of the Arrangement would be the ability to potentially repatriate business profits from Taiwan as “exempt surplus” free from Canadian tax. However, there is at least a technical concern that the Arrangement might not be considered to be a qualifying agreement or convention for the purposes of Canada’s “foreign affiliate” rules (and certain other provisions of the Income Tax Act (Canada)). Hopefully, the Canada Revenue Agency will provide clarity on this interpretive point in the near future.

by Michael Friedman and Carl Irvine

A Cautionary Note

The foregoing provides only an overview and does not constitute legal advice. Readers are cautioned against making any decisions based on this material alone. Rather, specific legal advice should be obtained.

© McMillan LLP 2016

Related Publications (5 Posts)

Featured Insight

The Canadian Capital Market is Psyched: An Update on the Growing Wave in the Psychedelics Industry

This bulletin provides an overview of the regulations surrounding psychedelics in Canada and psychedelics companies in the Canadian capital markets.

Read More
May 12, 2021
Featured Insight

Stopping a Slippery Slope: Ontario Divisional Court Clarifies that Auto Insurance Coverage Applies Only to Direct Causes of Injuries

Ontario Divisional Court clarifies that automobile insurance only applies to direct causes of injury under the Statutory Accidents Benefits Schedule.

Read More
May 12, 2021
Featured Insight

What Are You Suing Me For? I Had No Control: Lessor Fleet Liability

The decision in Barz concerns the interplay between Alberta’s Workers’ Compensation Act and Traffic Safety Act.

Read More
May 12, 2021
Featured Insight

Paid COVID-19 Sick Leave for British Columbia Employees

The British Columbia government has announced proposed amendments to the Employment Standards Act to provide for paid sick leave.

Read More
May 12, 2021
Featured Insight

A “vaccine break” for COVID-19 vaccination

Quebec follows the lead of the common law provinces taking legislative action to encourage vaccination.

Read More
May 12, 2021