


Supreme Court of Canada Grants Leave to Appeal in “Canada North” CCAA Priming Charges vs. Payroll Deductions Case
Supreme Court of Canada Grants Leave to Appeal in “Canada North” CCAA Priming Charges vs. Payroll Deductions Case
On March 26, 2020, the Supreme Court of Canada granted the application brought by the Federal Crown seeking leave to appeal the decision of the Alberta Court of Appeal in Canada v Canada North Group Inc., 2017 ABCA 314 (“Canada North”).
In Canada North, the Alberta Court of Appeal held that super-priority charges ordered by the court in Companies’ Creditors Arrangement Act (“CCAA”) proceedings may take priority over statutory deemed trust claims advanced by the Crown for unremitted payroll deductions. The deemed trust priority arises under the Income Tax Act (“ITA”), the Canada Pension Plan, and the Employment Insurance Act. Among other reasons, the Court held that granting priority to the Crown’s deemed trusts would produce absurd consequences by deterring necessary parties to a CCAA restructuring from getting involved due to the uncertainty of being paid. In a lengthy dissent, Justice Wakeling held that a plain interpretation of section 227(4.1) of the ITA entitles the Crown to priority over the debtor’s assets over any other creditor, including the beneficiaries of a court-ordered priming charge.
The outcome of the Supreme Court of Canada appeal in Canada North is of significant importance to those involved in commercial restructurings, including creditors, DIP lenders, court-appointed monitors, lawyers, and directors of debtor companies in CCAA proceedings. We will be watching this decision closely and will provide updates as soon as they are available.
For further background on the Canada North decision please see McMillan’s Bulletin entitled Alberta Court of Appeal Ranks CCAA Super-priority Charges Ahead of CRA’s Deemed Trust, but Uncertainty Remains.
by Preet Saini, Kourtney Rylands and Adam Maerov
A Cautionary Note
The foregoing provides only an overview and does not constitute legal advice. Readers are cautioned against making any decisions based on this material alone. Rather, specific legal advice should be obtained.
© McMillan LLP 2020
Insights (5 Posts)
Exemption for CBCA Reporting Issuers from Uncontested Director Election Proxy Form Requirements
The CSA published an exemption for CBCA-incorporated reporting issuers from the form of proxy requirement for uncontested election of directors.
Just the Facts Please! A Discussion of Limitation Periods for Environmental Claims
This Bulletin considers how limitation periods apply to environmental claims in Ontario and how to reduce the risk of missing one.
The Energy Statutes Amendment Act – British Columbia Welcomes the Hydrogen Industry
British Columbia’s Energy Statutes Amendment Act makes sweeping changes to the regulation of energy in British Columbia.
Capital Markets: 2022 Legal Year in Review
McMillan LLP's Capital Markets & Securities Group discuss the key legal developments in Canadian capital markets in 2022.
Greening Procurement in Canada: New Implications for the Construction Industry and Beyond
Two new standards under Canada's Policy on Green Procurement impose greenhouse gas emissions disclosure obligations on federal departments and contractors.
Get updates delivered right to your inbox. You can unsubscribe at any time.