Digital Brain
digital brain
digital brain

Canada Partners with the European Commission to Examine Use of Digital Credentials

December 7, 2021 Privacy and Cyber-Security Bulletin 4 minute read

With an increasing number of human interactions taking place in the digital world, there is a growing need for efficient and secure digital services.

To that end, Innovation, Science and Economic Development Canada recently announced a partnership between the Government of Canada and the European Commission to examine the use of digital credentials.[1] Standards for digital credentials are intended to improve privacy and global functionality, allowing governments and businesses (and their customers) to feel more secure in using such credentials.

Notably, Ontario has already begun developing its Digital Identity Program, which will provide a digital option for government issued identification in the province.[2]

What are digital credentials?

As the name suggests, digital credentials are the digital equivalents of ordinary physical credentials, such as passports, licenses, diplomas, educational certificates or tickets. They may appear as a badge in an email signature, an identification card in a digital wallet, or a certificate on a company’s website.

Digital credentials are generally used for the same purposes as their physical counterparts, including to confirm a person’s identity or qualifications. In order to perform this authentication function reliably and efficiently, digital credentials often have confirmatory information built right into the digital credential, in a manner that is difficult to fake. For example, a digital driver’s license may have meta-data or a digital watermark that includes the subject’s name, birthdate or photograph. The digital credential may also provide a method to automatically confirm the credential online with its source, such as through a verifiable data registry.[3]

In the private sector, businesses might use digital credentials externally (e.g., for membership and loyalty or rewards programs with customers) or internally (e.g., to verify education credentials and certifications in the hiring process). Businesses may also use digital credentials to verify an individual’s identity or to serve as proof of purchase (e.g., an airline ticket or conference admission pass).

The aim of digital credentials is to increase security, accessibility and efficiency when operating and interacting online. By allowing individuals to prove certain credentials about themselves, digital credentials are intended to provide a more privacy-friendly alternative to centralized digital user records or traditional paper records.

What came from this partnership?

Canada and the European Commission explored the use of digital credentials through workshops examining (i) the current technology and policy landscapes, (ii) areas of commonality, and (iii) gaps that need to be addressed to enable mutual support for the use of digital credentials.

There are several key gaps and challenges highlighted in the report from these workshops (the “Report”)[4], which center on the need for consistent standards.

The Report found that a variety of digital credential technologies already exist across different economic sectors and jurisdictions, which has led to the development of different standards in isolation. The Report noted that having disparate systems could lead to challenges for mutual recognition and scalability of digital credential systems. To address this, the Report recommends that both jurisdictions adhere to internationally recognized best practices and comply with endorsed principles of online interface design.

The Report also identified a lack of standards for digital wallets, which, like physical wallets, allow individuals to store and maintain digital credentials and other assets. The Report concluded that such standards are necessary to ensure the privacy and security of digital wallets.

Finally, the Report noted a risk that, as digital credential standards are developed, businesses and consumers may become dependent on larger players in the space, leading to reduced competition. The Report recommends open standards and a feature-agnostic system to address this problem.

To address these gaps and further advance the development of standards for digital credentials across Canada and the European Union, the Report provides a number of recommendations, including:

  • hosting digital credential showcases to build adoption, awareness, support and continuing engagement through both formal and informal channels;
  • implementing cross-border certification of academic diplomas to increase interoperability between Canada and the European Union; and
  • establishing mutual recognition for digital credentials through formal agreements between Canada and the European Union.

What should businesses know?

The increased collaboration between Canada and the European Union signals that both jurisdictions wish to clarify and bolster international standards and policies relating to digital credentials.

Now is a good time for businesses that have not made use of digital credentials to consider how using such systems could improve the privacy, efficiency, and security of their online interactions. Businesses looking to start using digital credentials should consider industry best practices, as these will likely inform any forthcoming policies and standards.

Businesses that already use digital credentials should consider whether their own practices with respect to digital credentials are reliable and whether they have sufficient privacy protections in place for digital credentials they manage.

Likewise, businesses that develop and offer products or services related to digital credentials should be alert to potential forthcoming guidelines, policies and/or legislative changes in Canada as a result of this ongoing collaboration.

Overall, the Report should be well received by international companies that make use of digital credentials in both the European Union and Canada, as unified standards of digital credentials may help create more business efficiencies and opportunities for collaboration across these jurisdictions.

With ongoing communication and engagement, policies and standards in this area will continue to change. We recommend reaching out to our Privacy and Data Protection team for any questions or concerns about the use of digital credentials.

[1] Canada, Innovation, Science and Economic Development Canada, News Release, Government of Canada announces partnership with the European Commission to examine the use of digital credentials (Ottawa: Innovation, Science and Economic Development Canada, 2021).
[2] Government of Ontario, Digital ID in Ontario  (November 2021).
[3] This is the manner in which the Ontario government has proposed to authenticate its digital identification cards: see Government of Ontario, Ontario’s Digital ID: Technology and Standards  (September 2021).
[4] Canada, Innovation, Science and Economic Development Canada, Canada and the European Union Joint Workshop Series for Enabling Interoperability and Mutual Support for Digital Credentials: Report on the Technical and Policy Workshops Held from Spring to Summer 2021 (Ottawa: Innovation, Science and Economic Development Canada, 2021).

by Robbie Grant, Kristen Pennington and Kristen Shaw (Articled Student)

 

Insights (5 Posts)

Featured Insight

Developer Wins Case Against a Montreal Borough After it Refuses to Issue a Construction Permit in the Context of a Site Planning and Architectural Integration Program (SPAIP)

This bulletin discusses a recent decision in which the court found in favour of a developer who sued a borough in connection with an urban planning matter.

Read More
Dec 7, 2022
Featured Insight

Prior Employee Experience May Enhance Common Law Entitlements

proper termination practices, punitive damages, moral damages, wrongful dismissal damages

Read More
Dec 7, 2022
Featured Insight

Public Consultation Related to Proposed Amendments to the Trademarks Regulations in Canada

Public consultations on proposed amendments to the Canadian Trademark Regulations are underway. Please see this bulletin for more information.

Read More
Dec 7, 2022
Featured Insight

Privacy, Technology and Cybersecurity Issues in Tech Transactions

Full evaluation of a target's privacy, technology and cybersecurity compliance in due diligence is critical for transactions involving technology companies.

Read More
Dec 6, 2022